Commentary

Commentary |

on No Judgment, essays by Lauren Oyler

“Does Oyler know that her negative reviews have had an impact? Sure. Does she care? She doesn’t … not care, but observes that caring too much about it is playing a different game than what the critic does.”

Commentary |

on The Upstate, poems by Lindsay Turner

“The poems generate a sense of depletion. They also come across as casually and glancingly violent (roadkill and dogfights), generic (strip malls and parking lots), and contaminated (haze and smog).”

Commentary |

on Craft: A Memoir by Tony Trigilio

“Developing one’s craft and then presuming to share the results is what he calls ‘an honorable form of audacity,’ based on the belief that you have done well and have something to share.”

Commentary |

on Was It for This, poems by Hannah Sullivan

“The trouble isn’t lack of variety but a certain density of purpose, stretching readers’ attention on little to no stakes; not so much idée fixe as fixation itself, an emotional treadmill …”

Commentary |

on Fallen Angel: The Life of Edgar Allan Poe by Robert Morgan

“Morgan establishes that even with Poe’s odd proclivities, life-threating addictions, and precarious and incessant need to be loved, he will always be ‘one of the most deeply moral writers in our canon.'”